Climate and Nature Bill: an interpretation of its ‘debate’ and adjournment
If you have been following the news closely in the last few days, you may have seen that the Climate and Nature Bill was debated in parliament on Friday. Unfortunately, after an 11th hour deal between Labour and the Lib Dems, the motion was not brought to a vote, but deferred until 11th July. However, this means it is unlikely to be heard, as it will not be the first item on the agenda on that day, unless the government chooses to prioritise it, which seems unlikely.
Five of us were in London, having been invited by our MP, Manuela Perteghella, to watch this unfold. As the ‘debate’ unfolded, the vast majority of speeches seemed to be in support of the Bill. MPs spoke movingly of the evidence on climate change, the decline of the natural environment in their lifetime, the rise of climate disasters, and the positive work unfolding in their constituencies. Clive Lewis (Labour) and Simon Hoare (Conservative) challenged Rachel Reeves’ devotion to ‘growth of any kind’, and in particular her desperate commitment to new runways at Heathrow. The debate was interrupted by a scheduled announcement of an arms contract with Rolls Royce – highly unusual in such a debate.
The government benches seemed relatively empty, and most of those speaking from that side seemed to be supporting the Bill. Andrew Bowie spoke against the Bill for the Conservatives, but was supported by only a couple of his colleagues on the Conservative benches. The Greens were all there and the Lib Dems out in force. The pro-Palestine independents were there, the SNP and Labour Left absent. Nigel Farage sat there quietly for a couple of hours before disappearing. It seemed that if a vote had been held at that time, it would be likely the Bill would pass. This seemed very incongruous in light of apparently well-informed reporting from the Guardian, that the government was manoeuvring to defeat the Bill.
What was going on finally became apparent (at 12:23) in the speech of Carla Denyer (Green), who revealed that the Bill’s promoter, Ros Savage MP, had agreed not to push the Bill to a vote, in exchange for further meetings with the government, and some additional concessions (see below). Ms Denyer threatened, as one of the Bill’s co-proposers, to take the Bill to a vote, if the government refused to commit to ‘real, binding, bold legislation that reflects the way in which the science has evolved since the Climate Change Act 2008’. This led to several accusations from Labour and Lib Dem MPs that Ms Denyer was ‘playing politics’, ‘undermining consensus’, etc. Ms Denyer was somewhat delegitimised in the process, being ‘constructed as hostile’, as one of my companions astutely put it. Ms. Savage also revealed her thinking in accepting the government’s deal: ‘there is a reason that I chose to come to this place: to take the policy approach. As the third party, the only way we can do that is by working with the Government.’
As a summary, the government are understood to have agreed to:
- A series of meetings with those behind the CAN Bill to work on “taking forward” the ideas of the CAN Bill, potentially in legislation.
- An annual statement from the Secretary of State on progress towards UK Net Zero targets which will be debated in parliament.
- Greater public involvement in climate policy. I have been told that this will involve a new forum joining government departments (DEFRA, DESNZ), climate campaigners and NGOs that will meet regularly to appraise progress.
- A video statement making these commitments public (view it here).
- Govt. will bring forward a number of their manifesto climate commitments so that they happen earlier rather than later such as the Land Use Framework, ratifying the BBNJ (Global Ocean Treaty) and ensuring closer collaboration between the JNCC and the CCC.
Arguably some of these things are good, but as Ms Denyer pointed out, the government has basically committed to none of the main provisions of the CAN Bill. Nor were there positive indications in the speech, Mary Creagh, Under-Secretary at DEFRA, made on behalf of the government during the debate. She referenced several of the key provisions of the Bill in her speech, making it clear that the government does not intend to adopt them:
- On improving government targets on climate and nature: ‘I share [Ms Savage’s] passion for measurable, specific, time-bound targets with clear Government plans to underpin them in order to achieve progress. What we can say, and what the Climate Change Committee has said, is that the previous Government were strong on long-term targets but very short on interim targets to get us to those places. We cannot will the ends without willing the means.’ This suggests Labour might set stronger near-term targets than the Conservatives. Yet later on, Ms Creagh seemed to simply claim credit for the existing targets, which were in fact set by the Conservatives: ‘We are proud to have set legally binding targets through the Climate Change Act to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions. We are committed to 13 legally binding environmental targets under the Environment Act, and halting the decline in species by 2030 is certainly very ambitious.’ So, existing targets are affirmed, and no new emissions targets are mentioned, and the improvement over the Conservatives seems to consist solely in pretending that targets set under them were in fact set by Labour. The Bill’s requirement of an increase in ambition from halting to reversing the decline of nature is likewise rejected.
- On a Citizens’ Assembly: ‘We agree that engagement with and access to nature provides clear benefits, and we want to help drive action for the environment, including through volunteering, citizen science, and building the innate connection and care that we all have in respect of the natural world. We will design our plan with users, and we have agreed to look forward further with young people and get them engaged in this process, as we did during the climate COP.’ So, footsoldier-level involvement and vetted consultations, rather than a Citizens’ Assembly.
- On interlinking the Climate and Nature Crises: ‘we are going to strengthen the relationship between the JNCC, the CCC and the special representatives, because the siloed approach to climate and nature respectively is dividing work.’ Arguably a good thing, but much weaker than the requirement s of the Bill. One could of course, argue the case for this – but the government has not done so.
- On requirements to reduce our overseas emissions/emissions from production of goods consumed in the UK: ‘We will look at strengthening data reporting on our consumption emissions, and at narratives concerning the imported emissions to which the Bill refers.’ So no targets, just reporting.
- Other provisions: The Bill’s requirements that fossil fuels be phased out as quickly as possible, and that job and retraining opportunities in the green economy be made available to people and areas likely to lose jobs in the fossil fuel economy were not mentioned at all.
After Ms Creagh’s speech, the debate was brought to a halt, with Christian Wakeford, MP, immediately calling for an adjournment of the debate. By this time, the government benches had noticeably swelled to a clear majority (with these late arrivals included local Warwickshire MPs, Matt Western and John Slinger). The adjournment motion was voted through, 120 to 7 (with the Lib Dems and some Labour MPs abstaining on the vote, leaving only the Greens, the pro-Palestine independents and one Tory MP voting against adjournment). I don’t know what happened to Carla Denyer’s threat to bring the Bill to a vote: whether she backed down in the face of the moral pressure directed against her, or whether the opportunity to do this was missed, or removed, by the adjournment motion. The Bill will be adjourned to the agenda of July 11th, but as it will not be the first Private Members’ Bill on that day’s agenda, it will probably not receive significant parliamentary time again, unless the government chooses to allow it. By way of illustration, after the debate finished there was time for 20 minutes ‘debate’ of another Bill, on gambling, which was then also adjourned to the 11th July.
Interpretation
The ‘debate’ was something of a show then, covering the real political process, which had gone on behind the scenes in a very dubious negotiation. There seemed to be a worrying agreement among some Labour and Lib Dem MPs that this is how politics should be done.
Re. climate targets, it should be noted that the debate refers primarily to the 2030 carbon budget, which the CAN Bill calls to be aligned with Net Zero. Our 2035 carbon budget, which is already legally binding under the Climate Change Act, is already aligned with our international commitments under the Paris Agreement. Labour will soon be required to set a target for 2040, under the Climate Change Act, and as the 2035 target is Net Zero aligned, presumably the 2040 one will be too. I would anticipate that Labour will attempt to present this as a concession to the CAN Bill campaigners, but this legerdemain should be rejected: the debate over the CAN Bill concerned the much nearer 2030 target, not the 2040 target.
Astonishingly, the Guardian has reported the government threatening to revise down our international commitments under the Paris Treaty if introduced into law under the CAN Bill, presumably again meaning our 2030 NDC. This might be considered a bluff: it might not have been feasible, given the existing, legally binding Net Zero target of 2050, the requirements of the CAN Bill, and the technical nature of target-setting.
What should we make of the split over tactics among the Bill’s supporters, foremost between Ros Savage and Carla Denyer? Ms Savage clearly felt that, with the government’s parliamentary majority as big as it is, working with them on terms they find acceptable is the only way to achieve legislative impacts. On this perspective, by agreeing to meet with the government, Ms Savage has salvaged the Bill from total rejection and secured a ‘seat at the table’ with the government, an ability to influence which, backed by the climate NGOs, could yield results. Against this, Ms Denyer could clearly have argued that by forcing a vote, supporters of the Bill would have forced Labour to either whip their MPs to vote against the Bill. Whilst this would have meant the Bill failing, the reputational damage incurred by the government and the backlash among their own MPs would put more effective pressure on them to bring forward climate legislation to repair the damage. Which of these approaches is right? The proof of the pudding will be in the eating: will the process of negotiation succeed in realising any of the Bill’s key elements? The above analysis of Ms Creagh’s speech suggests it will not.
The process of negotiation also merits comment. The difference in tactics could not be effectively debated amongst all the formalised parliamentary speechifying, and clearly this should have occurred beforehand. That it did not can be blamed on the government, as per Ms. Denyer:
They ignored the CAN Bill campaign for months, only finally agreeing to meet its promoter 10 days before this debate—coming to the negotiation table with almost nothing new, demanding a promise not to push the Bill it to a vote in exchange for no regulation, no legislation, no new targets. That is peanuts. After 10 days of negotiation, incredibly, the offers got worse—until, late last night, the best that the Government could offer was a meeting with the Secretary of State, a non-specific offer to work together, and a video.
It is clear the government does not want to pass the Bill, but that it also wanted to avoid: a) a rebellion among their MPs, which might be enough to pass it, and which would increase their discontent; b) the reputational damage from being seen to publicly kill a landmark piece of environmental legislation (though, announcing airport expansions as part of a desperate ploy for ‘growth’ will cause that too …). Moreover, they did not want to argue their position openly, or feel confident doing so – unlike the Conservatives, who have been arguing we already have the necessary legislation in place.
On a charitable interpretation, the government’s negotiation strategy could be seen as simple disorganization. On a more cynical interpretation – reinforced by the brinkmanship revealed in the Guardian’s reporting – the government can be seen as deliberately using Trump-style ‘art of the deal’ techniques to get their way. Waiting until the last minute to negotiate presumably made communication and development of a shared, consensual position among the Bill’s 12 co-proposers, extremely difficult. As it transpired, the negotiation and the decision not to push the Bill to a vote seems to have been largely conducted by Ms Savage alone. By delaying negotiations the government was able to secure a negotiating situation in which they were negotiating with someone who has been an MP for less than a year, a situation highly advantageous to getting their way, which Ms Savage, a new MP, admitted in her speech has been a baptism of fire. Whether by design or not, the government undeniably succeeded in outmanoeuvring the CAN Bill’s supporters to achieve – from their perspective – a best possible result: kicking the CAN Bill into the long grass without making meaningful concessions, avoiding a backbencher rebellion and serious reputational damage, and also damaging relationships among the backers of the CAN Bill into the bargain.
In this light, the criticism of Ms Denyer for refusing to participate in ‘grown up politics’ should be seen as gaslighting, particularly when it came from Ms Creagh.
But it is also legitimate to ask how it was that Ms Savage acquired the right to negotiate on behalf of all of us, given that the CAN Bill was supposed to be a piece of consensual, cross-party legislation, developed and supported by scientists and climate NGOs, backed by activists across the country. In her speech Ms Denyer recognised Ms Savage as having the right to make this decision, so it seems that this was not just a matter of Ms Savage taking things into her own hands. But surely its fate should not have been entrusted to the decision of one relatively inexperienced MP, in negotiation with a government holding all the cards. Whatever Ms Savage’s formal rights as promoter of the Bill, there was also the question of the moral right of the lobby behind the Bill to be better represented in these decisions, and Ms Savage legitimately could, and should, have refused to negotiate on the government’s schedule, without more time for consultation with the Bill’s co-supporters. This would have required recognising the point made above: that forcing the government to stand against the Bill would have damaged their reputation among backbenchers and the public, and forced them to make meaningful concessions.
In short, the CAN Bill backers seem to have failed to recognise the extent of their power in the negotiations. It would be good to see a little less deference and a little more willingness to play hardball in our climate leaders.