By Stephen Norrie.
Road transport is the single biggest source of greenhouse gas emissions in Stratford District. According to a recent report, prepared by Anthesis for Stratford District Council, it is responsible for 45.1% of local emissions. Anthesis say we need to reduce these emissions by 83% by 2030, to meet our targets under the Paris agreement. How can we do this?
Electric vehicles alone won’t be enough. For one thing, the government is only banning the sale of new petrol and diesel vehicles from 2030. The rate of take-up of electric vehicles is increasing fast, but as of September, only 0.5% of UK vehicles were electric. Moreover, according to the National Audit Office, emissions reductions from electric vehicle uptake are being cancelled out by increasing numbers of cars and the trend for SUVs.
For another thing, electric vehicles won’t be zero carbon until there’s enough renewable energy to power both their production and use. Replacing all the vehicles on the road with electric vehicles is a massive undertaking which, under present conditions, will still carry a high carbon cost. Producing so many electric vehicles will also be difficult due to likely resource bottlenecks in the supply of key minerals used in batteries.
So, to reduce emissions, we also need to reduce the number of vehicles on our roads. According to one study, from the University of Valladolid, achieving net zero by 2050 will require a 60% reduction in global inland and water transport.
Politicians sometimes seem to recognise this, and initiatives to increase cycling provision are very welcome. However, we’re still relentlessly building more and more roads. The government plans to spend £27 billion on new road infrastructure, whilst locally, plans for a South-Western Relief Road have yet to be dropped. The problem, as many studies have shown, is that building or expanding roads leads to more cars on the road. In the literature, this phenomenon is known as induced traffic.
This can be explained in terms of the simple economic logic of supply and demand: when a good becomes cheaper, more people will buy it. Think of time spent in traffic as part of the ‘cost’ of driving. If building more roads decreases the time spent in traffic, thereby decreasing this ‘cost’, people—and planners—are going to make more use of the roads. Though this simple supply and demand logic doesn’t hold in all cases, studies show this is what happens with driving. A 2017 study commissioned by the Campaign for the Protection of Rural England found average traffic increases of 7% over 3-7 years, and of 47% over 8-20 years.
This can be down to people making journeys they wouldn’t otherwise make, or travelling further for e.g. leisure. It can be due to the presence of roads leading to additional car-dependent development. If people shift from trains or buses, as car-use becomes more convenient, those services may be cut back, making them more inconvenient still.
What’s the solution? By the logic of induced travel, if congestion is part of the ‘time-price’ of driving, trying to reduce it is a trap. Rather, our focus should be on increasing this inconvenience, whilst making sure more convenient alternatives are put in place wherever possible. Road congestion will decrease when this balance induces people to get out of their cars.
There are many ways of achieving this, from making over road space to buses and bikes, reducing town centre parking, reducing speed limits, and workplace parking charges. Perhaps we should be talking about turning motorway lanes into coach-lanes. Of course, it will be important to do this intelligently, so as not to penalise the disabled or poor. But does anyone have an alternative?