Renewables Can Be Reliable

By John Stott.

It is often said that renewables cannot supply reliable electricity because there are times when the wind is weak and/or the sun not shining. But renewables already provide, on an annual basis, over 40% of our electricity and this is set to increase considerably. New renewable electricity is many times cheaper than gas fired power and much cheaper than nuclear.

The variability of renewable output is well known and has many solutions some of which are currently being introduced to the UK electricity grid. These are: –

  1. Increased connections to grids in neighbouring countries (we already have 7 inter-connectors). This helps, because when renewable output is low in the UK, a nearby country will have wind and/or lots of sunshine.
  2. The UK grid now has a useful amount of battery storage, and this is increasing rapidly.
  3. Pumped storage systems where spare electricity is used to pump water from a low-lying lake to one on higher ground, so that when extra power is needed, hydro power can be generated by reversing the flow. Plans are in place for more of these, especially in Scotland.
  4. Using spare power to make liquid CO2. As with pumped storage, the energy captured in the liquid can be stored for long periods and when required, converted back to electricity by allowing the CO2 to boil and expanding the gas through a turbine. The CO2 is in a closed system either as liquid or as gas so does not harm the climate. Lakes at the top and bottom of a hill are not required so liquid CO2 storage can be built anywhere. The system is nearly as efficient as batteries, much cheaper per unit of electricity supplied and has a longer service life. This new technology is likely to become a key feature in electricity grids.
  5. Building excess renewable capacity, which for most of the time can be used to make liquid fuels for aircraft or hydrogen to feed into the gas grid, but in times of low wind or sun, will still be able to meet demand. In Shetland, excess wind power is already being converted to hydrogen to power ferries.
  6. Building tidal lagoon power stations, however the government has so far blocked this technology, even though it is cheaper than new nuclear. It is more expensive than wind and solar but has the great advantage of predictability. The tide turns at different times around our coast so when, around high or low water, one tidal power station is paused the others would still be generating.

The graph above is for December 2022. You can get a recent one here. When it is windy (blue line), power from gas (red line) is low and vice versa. Notice the particularly low gas power on the nights of 18th//19th, 19th/20th, & 30th. We are getting close to the point when, at times, demand will be met, for short periods at first, entirely by a combination of renewables, nuclear, storage and imports (also shown on the Gridwatch website).

So, a combination of the measures mentioned above will enable a fully renewable electricity grid and partially decarbonise the gas grid. We need these measures in place and the right level of investment in them to make that happen if we are to meet our Net Zero targets.