Guidance on responding to the South Warwickshire Local Plan, Preferred Options Consultation

If you have time before the end of Friday, please take time to respond to the next stage in the consultation on the South Warwickshire Local Plan. This will set rules for construction in South Warwickshire over the next few decades, so it’s pretty important to limiting CO2 emissions, and ensuring space and money is allocated for renewable energy, nature recovery, etc. You can also answer questions about individual sites where development might be planned.

You can respond to the consultation here. Questions mostly ask whether you are in favour of each policy (or ‘Draft Policy Direction’) and then you can add a comment as well. There’s also broader questions on the approach taken in each Chapter. You don’t have to respond to every question.  

Our Chair, Stephen, has put together some notes on how he’s responding to the consultation below, which you might (or might not) find useful. 

One of the most important issues is that, whilst the existing document is pretty good on building standards for housing, it doesn’t require carbon footprinting of transport infrastructure projects, or sufficiently recognise that  building roads leads to more car journeys and must therefore be at the bottom of a hierarchy of transport solutions. If you only respond to one question, please respond to the question about  Draft Policy Direction 31 to say this.

Notes by Chapter:

I’ll skip the introductory chapters (in which there is nothing really to object to) and provide guidance on the substantive ones, starting with Chapter 4. 

Chapter 4 is about overall quantities of housing they are going to plan for, where it might go, and associated issues. The focus is generally on putting it on brownfield sites and near existing transport infrastructure. I’m not going to oppose their overall numbers as I lack the expertise to do so and their methodology seems reasonable.

If you know specific sites, please comment on those. There are more sites selected for possible development than will actually be developed, so feel free to mention any advantages or disadvantages of particular sites. If you play around with the mapping tool on the consultation website, you can see that quite a few of them incorporate strands of land that belong to flood plains, and a lot also include woodlands, ancient woodlands, nature sites, etc. I don’t know if this means these are threatened, but certainly we shouldn’t be cutting down mature woodlands to build houses, or building on flood plains, and if that is intended, it would contradict policies in Chapter 11.

The main points to comment on are the transport projects for which land is being protected. Some of these involve road building, so responding to DPD6 is an opportunity to get across the message that these “traffic flow improvements” will only lead to more people getting in their cars and driving further. 

I’m going to support protecting land for potential reopening of the Honeybourne railway line. Not everyone in our group is in favour of this (some feel it would do to much damage to the existing “greenway” cycle path along the railway line; the expert view is there is enough space for both). The conversation as to what is best is ongoing though, so safeguarding the land makes sense.

I disagree with the Wildlife Trust’s position on building on Green Belt land: The name “Green Belt” is really deceptive: it isn’t an environmental designation, it’s a corset to prevent Birmingham and Coventry getting ever bigger, intended to maintain the distinction of settlements. That’s probably a good idea on the whole, but existing designation is total overkill on this front. All the land north of Stratford is green belt, all the land south of Stratford isn’t, but taken in the whole, the land is largely the same – farmland in the north is no more biodiverse, or more “green”, than in the south. So there’s no reason, from a nature perspective, to insist that development should only take place to the south. And as there’s no transport infrastructure there, that will cause massive problems and require loads of new roads, etc, leading to bigger increases in CO2 emissions. 

So I’m planning to support Draft Policy Directions 1 (housing no.s), 2 (new settlements), 3 (settlement boundaries, etc), 4 (housing needs from outside the area), 7 (green belt), 8 (densification) and 9 (using brownfield land).

I think DPD 5 could be stronger and make its rationale clearer: the aim is to ensure new developments include infrastructure (local shops, schools, etc) so people don’t have to travel so much. Active and public transport should be prioritised. I’ll mention that in the comment. But in general I’m in favour.

Chapter 5, Delivering Homes that Meet the Needs of All our Communities, is mostly fine, and I’ll support most of it. I’ll make a few comments.

Most substantively, Draft Policy A sets a minimum size for homes. I think there should be a maximum size too (for loads of reasons: implications for land, energy use and urban density and inequality).

Chapter 6 is on locations for Employment Growth. It mostly seems to make sense. I’ll probably disagree with their plans for protecting Wellesbourne Airfield for aviation in DPD 16, but it’s not the biggest issue.

Chapter 7 is the one most directly linked to GHG emissions reductions. They’ve done a lot of hard work on buildings standards, and I think what they’ve come up with is pretty good, so I’m intending to be complimentary about this. Most of the policies are really good. Especially the policies on building standards (most of DPD 22, DPD 23, 24) deserve praise: they are going beyond national building standards, especially on embodied carbon (DPD 24) and have sunk a lot of work into justifying this.

But I do have two big concerns:

* The policy on renewable energy (Draft Policy D) is mostly fine, except that they apply a condition (condition f) to onshore wind proposals which, on my reading, would make them impossible. It requires all possible impacts identified by the local community to be “fully” mitigated: this would include visual impacts, which at least some people will always complain about, and which it will not be possible to fully mitigate against. The earlier condition (b) already allows for reasonable consideration of landscape impacts, so this condition should be removed.

* I’m also concerned about the ventilation hierarchy in DPD 22 and Draft Policy G. They suggest passive ventilation (e.g. trickle vents) should be higher priority than mechanical ventilation. But passive ventilation can’t be reconciled with the high degrees of airtightness needed to avoid heat loss, which is why the Passivhaus model relies on mechanical ventilation. There’s a risk of encouraging damp-prone housing here.

Chapter 8 seems mostly fine. I thought DPD 28, on encouraging use of our waterways, might contain something about decarbonising canal boats.

Chapter 9 – a short chapter on on pollution and health. It seems fine, I’ll support what’s there.

Chapter 10 is on transport, and leaves a lot to be desired. What is there sounds ok from an environmental standpoint, but key points are missing, and it needs to be a lot stronger. If you compare it to Chapter 7, where they show they’ve done a lot of work, and provide discussions of the principles underpinning their decisions, it’s clear they just haven’t done the same amount of work here.

There is no mention of induced travel dynamics: levels of road travel demand are not fixed but respond to the amount of road – and non-road – transport infrastructure provided. So – to simplify – if you have a congested road, and you build more lanes, more people drive, and you just end up with a bigger traffic jam with more cars in it. Or, alternatively, if you don’t build those extra lanes, but put in a good cycling system, the congestion is part of what drives uptake of cycling. So, as every sustainable transport strategy says we need to get cars off the road, the implication is that road-building should in general be avoided. A hierarchy of transport options (like e.g. the Sustainable Accessibility and Mobility (SAM) Framework) which puts road-building at the bottom should be included. 

There also needs to be a requirement for evaluations of the consequences for carbon emissions of all transport infrastructure. 

There’s also nothing here about support for pedestrianisation, 20 mph speed limits, traffic calming measures, road-narrowing, or even on how integrated cycle networks, cycle storage in town centres, multi-modal mobility hubs, etc are to be supported.

DPD 31 is the main point where I’m going to say all this, but maybe also in the question at the end, about whether we support the approach of the chapter as a whole. 

I’m not quite sure what to made of the policy on EV charging? (DPD 32) I think the focus on increasing equality of access is admirable, and that putting EV chargers in Council car parks made sense, but I can’t imagine people in social housing driving down to a car park to use a charger there. So I don’t see how Council car park chargers will help address inequality, which seems the theory behind the policy. This is DPD 32. Not sure if I’m going to support or vote “other” on this one.

I’m ok with DPDs 33 & 34. DPD 35 is on smart cities. The technological vision they set out in the policy itself is (IMO) fine. But it’s not narrowly a technical issue: bear in mind that an American tech billionaire will likely be owning the software used to run these smart cities, using our data and sucking rents out of the area and across the Atlantic, you might want to comment on that. Not sure local Councils have it in their power to set up an alternative, but maybe worth mentioning to stimulate thought about these issues.

Chapter 11 is on biodiversity. The Warwickshire Wildlife Trust are quite critical of it, but I thought its main faults are that work that is being done on the Local Nature Recovery Strategy hasn’t been integrated yet, so I think some of their criticisms and negativity are a bit over-stated. See their position here: https://www.warwickshirewildlifetrust.org.uk/south-warwickshire-local-plan

Some are worried about the market mechanisms planned in DPDs 39 & 40 (and 41?). I think the hierarchy put in place does minimise the risks associated with offset trading though, and I’m not sure we can expect local councils to radically break with mainstream political economic frameworks. Worth mentioning though, if you’re concerned about this.

I did have some other problems:

The policy on trees and hedgerows (DPD 42) needs to value trees and hedgerows for their carbon sequestration and storage, as well as their ecological and amenity value. It shouldn’t be possible for a whole wood to be cut down to build houses, as happened at Mappleborough Green. I’m not confident the policy on carbon sinks (DPD 41) is strong enough to prevent this, so I think this needs to be added here. So I won’t be supporting this one.

The policy on outdoor sports & leisure (DPD 44) doesn’t recognise that they’re becoming increasingly unplayable due to waterlogging – there needs to be a more serious adaptation plan than is mentioned here. So I won’t be supporting this one either.

I might not support the proposal for a “buffer zone” around the existing Cotswold area of natural beauty (DPD 46) – nice idea, but I think we have bigger concerns at present.

DPD 49 on Agricultural Land is good, but people have mentioned that there should be more on future food supply in the plan, given future flooding/drought risks and adaptation needs. Perhaps that’s something to mention in the question at the end of this chapter, on whether we support the approach of the chapter as a whole.

You might find some of the above useful in responding to the questions about the broad approach of different chapters, and also the introductory chapters on overarching principles. I’d encourage you to fill these in too, and this is a place to say what’s missing. I’ll do that in Chapter 10, on transport (nothing on pedestrianisation, etc), and Chapter 11 (on missing treatment of food supply).