Listening to Facts isn’t Radical

By Niall Tucker, Stratford upon Avon Extinction Rebellion.

Rish Sunak said the following at COP28 earlier this month “the UK is leading the charge. We’re absolutely committed to our Net Zero targets.”

When I read this, this seemed to me a blatant untruth. The government’s own Climate Change Committee report in June said among its key messages:

  • There is a lack of urgency.
  • Expansion of fossil fuel production is not in line with Net Zero
  • Planning policy needs radical reform to support Net Zero.
  • Action is needed in a range of areas to deliver on the Government’s emissions pathway.
  • We should retake a clear leadership role internationally.

One would have thought the government would heed this report and take meaningful action to address the issues mentioned. Surprisingly, the opposite happened in September. The government announced that they were removing or delaying some key policies in tackling the climate crisis. They included:

  • Scrapping policies to force landlords to upgrade the energy efficiency of their properties.
  • Pushing back the ban on new petrol and diesel cars to 2035.
  • Weakening the plan to phase out gas boilers from 2035.

How can Rishi Sunak say that the government is committed to our targets and leading the charge when they are doing the exact opposite?

United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres said at COP28 that “we cannot save a burning planet with a fire hose of fossil fuels,” adding that meeting a global goal of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius “is only possible if we ultimately stop burning all fossil fuels”. In June, he called for financial institutions to “commit to end financing and investment in exploration for new oil and gas fields, and expansion of oil and gas reserves” By contrast, our Prime Minister said in September “Using every last drop of North Sea oil is ‘absolutely the right thing to do”. Does this sound like “leading the charge”?

Our politicians have failed us over the past 33 years ever since the first COP. CO2 emissions have been going up every year (apart from the pandemic). Global average temperatures are much higher than they were in 1990. Despite all the words, governments and companies have failed to change this. Rishi Sunak is one in a long line of people who have made promises but failed to do enough to even slow climate change.

In the face of such inaction, it can be easy to be negative and give up hope. However, we in Stratford upon Avon Extinction Rebellion, have found hope by coming together and taking action as citizens. Since our inception in 2019, we have been carrying out peaceful, non-violent actions locally and elsewhere. The most powerful thing we do is listen to people and try to give everyone a voice. We are definitely not about making people feel guilty about their “personal carbon footprint”. This was a term popularised by the oil company BP, to try to shift the blame. The reality is there is limited impact an individual can make by only focusing on themselves. By contrast, we are trying to move together towards collective action.

Personally, I am involved in climate activism for my daughters and everyone else’s futures. I want to be able to look in my daughters’ eyes when they are older and say I did something. If we continue to make only marginal changes to our systems of living like we have done in the past 33 years, then CO2 levels will continue to rise and so temperatures will also rise leading to severe global issues.

We want a better future for everyone based on facts and science. It is achievable. We do not need any wonder technology. The technology exists today to tackle the climate crisis. One of the quickest and most effective ways to make a difference is to speak up. Talk to your neighbours, colleagues, friends, and family. No one can do it all alone – but we can do it together.

People in Extinction Rebellion are often painted as extremists or radical in the media. We are simply listening to the science and the facts. We would like the government to do the same. This doesn’t seem very radical to me.

This article was originally published in the Stratford Herald on December 14th 2023.